Skip Navigation

Blind Men Appraising an Elephant

Ohara Donshu

Asian Art

MEDIUM Ink and colors on paper
  • Place Made: Japan
  • DATES early 19th century
    PERIOD Edo Period
    DIMENSIONS Overall: 92 x 46 1/2 in. (233.7 x 118.1 cm) Image: 67 x 37 1/2 in. (170.2 x 95.3 cm)  (show scale)
    COLLECTIONS Asian Art
    MUSEUM LOCATION This item is not on view
    ACCESSION NUMBER 1993.57
    CREDIT LINE Gift of the Asian Art Council, Mr. and Mrs. Willard G. Clark, Georgia and Michael de Havenon, Mr. and Mrs. Greg Fitz-Gerald, Dr. and Mrs. George Liberman, and Khalil Rizk and Frank L. Babbott Fund
    RIGHTS STATEMENT No known copyright restrictions
    This work may be in the public domain in the United States. Works created by United States and non-United States nationals published prior to 1923 are in the public domain, subject to the terms of any applicable treaty or agreement.

    You may download and use Brooklyn Museum images of this work. Please include caption information from this page and credit the Brooklyn Museum. If you need a high resolution file, please contact reproductions@brooklynmuseum.org (charges apply).

    The Museum does not warrant that the use of this work will not infringe on the rights of third parties, such as artists or artists' heirs holding the rights to the work. It is your responsibility to determine and satisfy copyright or other use restrictions before copying, transmitting, or making other use of protected items beyond that allowed by "fair use," as such term is understood under the United States Copyright Act.

    The Brooklyn Museum makes no representations or warranties with respect to the application or terms of any international agreement governing copyright protection in the United States for works created by foreign nationals.

    For further information about copyright, we recommend resources at the United States Library of Congress, Cornell University, Copyright and Cultural Institutions: Guidelines for U.S. Libraries, Archives, and Museums, and Copyright Watch.

    For more information about the Museum's rights project, including how rights types are assigned, please see our blog posts on copyright.

    If you have any information regarding this work and rights to it, please contact copyright@brooklynmuseum.org.
    CAPTION Ohara Donshu (Japanese, died 1857). Blind Men Appraising an Elephant, early 19th century. Ink and colors on paper, Overall: 92 x 46 1/2 in. (233.7 x 118.1 cm). Brooklyn Museum, Gift of the Asian Art Council, Mr. and Mrs. Willard G. Clark, Georgia and Michael de Havenon, Mr. and Mrs. Greg Fitz-Gerald, Dr. and Mrs. George Liberman, and Khalil Rizk and Frank L. Babbott Fund , 1993.57
    IMAGE overall, 1993.57_IMLS_SL2.jpg. Brooklyn Museum photograph
    "CUR" at the beginning of an image file name means that the image was created by a curatorial staff member. These study images may be digital point-and-shoot photographs, when we don\'t yet have high-quality studio photography, or they may be scans of older negatives, slides, or photographic prints, providing historical documentation of the object.
    CATALOGUE DESCRIPTION The painting represents a large, benevolent, white elephant being examined by a group of figures, many of them blind. The blind men acquaint themselves with the elephant by touch, while those who can see either laugh at the event taking place in front of them or quietly queue up to take their turn to inspect it. The scene, known from sources throughout Asian literature and painting, is a metaphor for the human condition: each individual presumes to know the nature of the universe through his extremely limited personal experience of it. The subject is found in "Sketchbooks of Hoksai" ("Hokusai Manga") (1814-19), where a hulking elephant is shown in profile surrounded by miniscule blind figures. One blind man touches the trunk and exclaims: "Why an elephant is like a snake." Another, its tail: It's like a rope." Another, it's flank: "Like a wall." Expressive figures of blind men are frequently employed in later Japanese Buddhist painting to represent the vulnerable and precarious condition of those who are spiritually blind. The subject of blind men examining an elephant is found as early as the fifth century A. D. in the "Hitopadesha," the Indian version of Aesop's fables. The composition in the Donshu work closely follows an earlier Chinese precedent called "Washing the White Elephant," which we know from several late Ming examples, such as a painting by Ding Yungpeng of 1604, representing the annual event in China when the imperial court elephants were ritually cleaned (Hyland, "Deities, Emperors, Ladies and Literati; Figure Painting of the Ming and Qing Dynasties," Birmingham Museum of Art, 1987: Alabama, cat. # 20). Hokusai also treated this subject in Vol. 13 of the "Hokusai Manga" (c. 1849-50) (Hillier, "Hokusai Manga," fig # 40) although in Hokusai's version, the elephant is seen in profile. A more contemporary inspiration for later Japanese artists may have been the actual arrival in Japan, in 1978, of a white elephant brought from Siam, an event that appears to have generated a great deal of excitement. Ohara Donshu is a Kyoto painter of the Shijo School known for his wide variety of subjects and varied techniques. He is not, however, a typical Shijo painter. His work is sufficiently rare. Three paintings in the Ogino Collection, Kurashiki, Japan have been published: "A Fan Painting of Immortal Kinko" (The Suntory Museum Catalogue) Lady Playing a Zither; and the Chinese Literati landcape subject Lan-ting Pavilion. Donshu's abbreviated style can be associated with the haiga genre which is know for a sketchy, spontaneous technique often associated with haiku poems. Jack Hillier praises Donshu's work as a haiku illustrator and cites three additional paintings in Japanese Collection (Yabumoto and Richard Lane). Even more impressive than the published examples, the monumental scale of this painting is enhanced by the artist's detailed depiction of the elephant in dry brushwork and the animated figures surrounding it. He blurs the dry color applied to several patches of the figures' costumes, rather than laying it down in flat tints. The background is deliberately worked in serene gray washes. The painting came with an original wooden box on which the title "Elephant" and the artist's name "Donshu-hitsu (painted by)" were written. Condition: Good. There is scattered foxing throughout the paper and the green pigmants (probably of copper origin) have stained the paper where in contact. (See Record of Restoration File).
    RECORD COMPLETENESS Good (78%)
    Not every record you will find here is complete. More information is available for some works than for others, and some entries have been updated more recently. Records are frequently reviewed and revised, and we welcome any additional information you might have.